–they’re both large positive bets (large holdings) of hedge funds–and of many retail investors
–both have delivered weak performance over the past year, after extended periods of substantial gains. And the losses have occurred during a time of generally stable conditions for the world economy, with ample liquidity and strong inflows of money into financial products
–recent trading in both seems to me to be giving signs of forced or distressed selling
are these factors connected?
It’s hard to know, since global hedge fund disclosure is incomplete–and there’s ample evidence that what disclosure there is can’t be relied on. However, I think it’s reasonable to assume they are.
if so, what does this imply?
In my experience, a professional investor goes through a three-step process as he realizes he’s made a mistake–or that his previously good idea is no longer working. He:
–stops adding to the position when new money comes in, effectively shrinking its relative size,
–begins to sell, to further lessen the negative effect of the position on performance, and
–accelerates the selling when the position is small enough the extra visibility and extra downward pressure on price make little difference.
A professional investor can go through these states in the blink of an eye, or it can take a long period of time. A lot depends on style, self-awareness and how ugly the underperformance is. Anyone who operates on margin may also get additional feedback from his lenders.
Many retail investors, in my experience, just panic–very close to the bottom.
Recent price action in gold and in AAPL strike me as Stage-Three end-game activity–some combination of panic, response to margin calls and/or dumping of the remainders of positions being sold over long periods.
is this an opportunity to buy?
For me, the answer here is easy. It’s “No.” The key supply-demand issue is whether central banks in emerging markets will continue to buy gold in the aggressive way they have done over the past several years. I have no idea. So I’m clearly the “dumb money” in this arena–the strongest reason there is to stay away.
We’ll have more information tomorrow, after AAPL reports its latest quarterly earnings.
The stock is now trading at less than 9x historic earnings and yielding 2.7%. The shares have underperformed the S&P 500 by more than 50 percentage points since last September.
The company has no debt and its cash holdings are approaching almost half the market cap.
If there’s anything “wrong” with the stock, it’s that its fall from grace has been so extreme. That prompts the question, “What must sellers know that I don’t?”
How do you overcome aversion, based on an extended decline, to a stock that looks like a $100 bill lying on the street? The first step, I think, is to look for signs that the waves of selling that have pummeled AAPL are over. This means having AAPL announce bad news and have the stock go up, rather than sell of further. That’s why tomorrow’s earnings report may be important.