It was clear from the outset that the Trump economic program, which can be seen as a copy of Japan’s rebuilding plan after the devastation of WWII, would create a rocky road for the domestic economy.
The three main ideas are:
–depress the currency, which will
–make imports more expensive, and
–discourage the use of foreign-born workers.
In the case of Japan, it was well-understood that the then current generation would suffer substantial economic pain, but the next generation, and those following it, would be substantially better off.
Unlike Japan, however, Trump has added ICE violence and foreign prison camps to the anti-nonwhite immigrant violence. This has revived memories in the rest of the world of similar episodes in Russia and Germany. And, assuming press reports are correct, the war in Iran is being masterminded by a man nicknamed “NoTabs,” to underline his lack of military knowledge and the absence of leadership skills.
…a real mess.
Taking off one’s hat as a human being and replacing it with an investor’s cap, a very important question is how long the current state of affairs will last. It’s also the point of this post.
I divide this into two issues, and look at what stock prices are saying today:
–when will consumer spending begin to pick up? Given that consumers have generally been trading down, I think an uptick in the price of dollar store stocks (based presumably on better sales) will likely be a good indicator.
OLLI (Ollies Bargain Outlet), which I regard as the lowest end of the dollar store market is up by about 20% from its early-July bottom. Year to date, it’s down by -22.4%–compared with a rise in the S&P 500 by +12.5% and NASDAQ by +15.7%.
DG (Dollar General), the high end, is also up by about 20% from its low in May. Ytd, it’s down by a bit more than -6%.
If we move up a few notches to WMT (Walmart), it’s down by almost 20% from its mid-year high and is slightly above its early September low of ~$102.
My read is that there’s not much to write home about in the dollar store industry but if I had to guess–I don’t have the confidence to want to do more than watch at this point–I’d think we’ve already hit peak trading down.
How do I explain WMT? I think it’s the last retail shoe to drop.
–I held KSS (Kohl’s) for a while on the idea that the value of its brand name and store network might be enough to entice a foreign company to make a bid for it. If not KSS, then some other similar-style company. KSS is down by -10.5% ytd, and up from its mid-May low of $11.50 or so.
This compares with book value of about $35.
I have no strongly held opinion, but it seems to me that no bid at $12-minus implies that no bid is coming. Why not? My sense is that the main issue is not the incompetence of the current administration (when was the last time a Defense Secretary had “No Tabs” (a nickname I hadn’t heard before but which I interpret as somewhere between “no basic military officer training” and “clueless”)?) but the black eye that comes from the fact that Congress and the courts are allowing organizations like ICE to prosper.
Whatever the reason, no investors seem to want exposure to the US economy as it has been shaped by the adminstration.
It will be interesting to see if/how the upcoming election changes this narrative.