Last night after the market close, AAPL reported earnings per share that beat the consensus of Wall Street analysts–and the stock went down in the after-market. MSFT, in contrast, reported results that fell short of analysts’ estimates–and the stock went up!
What’s going on?
AAPL gave next-quarter guidance that fell below Wall Street’s projection–but it always does this, so that’s not the reason. MSFT’s income statement looks better after factoring out the large operating loss generated by Nokia, but I don’t think that’s the reason for the market’s positive response, either. After all, if you wanted to (I didn’t), you could have gotten a reasonable guess at how much Nokia would subtract from the MSFT total from Nokia’s recent results as a stand-alone company.
I think the market’s response is much more a a conceptual response.
Tim Cook has made it clear that AAPL is a manufacturer of high-end mobile consumer technology. There’s no “next big thing” on the horizon, however, with only a periodic refresh of the company’s smartphone line due any time soon. If reports from suppliers are accurate, new offerings will include a phone with a large, Samsung Galaxy-matching screen size, and a(n even larger) tablet/phone. For Jobs-ites, this departure from Steve’s view that phones should be small enough to operate with one hand may be earth-shaking. But for the rest of the world, this is only catching up to what Samsung already has on the market. So a ho-hum Wall Street response is appropriate.
For MSFT, on the other hand, the news is relatively better. The company seems to have a focus for the first time in a long while. The fact that Nokia is putting up operating losses at a near-$3 billion annual rate seems to me to justify the downsizing MSFT has recently announced. The only surprise is that this wasn’t started sooner.
Leaving the X-Box content creation business is probably more symbolic than anything else, but it removes a potential distraction–especially given the continual mess the company has typically made of its game software development efforts.
One, admittedly small, figure what caught my eye was that MSFT has added another 1,000,000 individual/small business users to its Office 365 rolls during the June quarter. I think this just shows the power of the cloud–easier administration, much lower cost-of-goods expense, and hugely better protection against counterfeiting.
For MSFT, then, the earnings were nice, but the fact that the company’s board is allowing significant changes is nicer. True, the message may turn out only to be that the company will try harder not to shoot itself in the foot again, but even that’s an uptick. Hence the positive market response. Absence of missteps won’t be good enough for long, but it’s ok for now.