Just at midnight, New York time, the Macau Gaming Coordination and Inspection Bureau (DICJ) posted its report of aggregate casino win for the SAR during October. The win, that is, the amount gamblers lost in the SAR, was MOP 28.0 billion (US$3.5 billion). That’s up by 9.8% month-on-month, but down 23.2% year-on-year.
The result had been widely anticipated–and heavily publicized by the companies themselves, the government of the SAR and Hong Kong-based securities analysts. Consensus estimates of the decline seem to me to have centered around -21% yoy.
The Hong Kong casino stocks were up a couple of percent in midday trading today when the DICJ report appeared. Despite the wide publicity, the stocks immediately lost all their morning gains. They drifted lower throughout the afternoon, ending down by around 3% for the day.
How could stocks drop 5% on news that had arguably so fully anticipated?
I don’t think it’s that win was down 23% instead of 21%. Both are equally weak. More likely, in my view, is that short-term traders used the DICJ report to take profits after the stocks’ 15% gains in recent weeks. It’s also possible that the market hadn’t grasped the current Macau casino situation as fully as I had thought. It could be, as well, that the discounting mechanism for stocks nowadays in Hong Kong works more like the bond market in the US (reacting to strongly to current news as it hits the media) than the stock market. (I doubt this last, but it has been a while since I devoted a serious chunk of my time to studying the Hong Kong market.)
I’m not in a huge rush to buy, partly because I already have a pretty full weighting, both through the Hong Kong stocks and through WYNN and LVS.
My working hypothesis is that cyclical lows–10%+ below today’s close–have already been made.
Could the stocks drop another 5% from here–i.e., get halfway back to the lows of September? …maybe, especially since the market upturn I anticipate will likely be in the spring or summer of 2015. But it would take at least that much to get me interested again. For now, I’m content to watch.