VZ is buying the 45% of Verizon Wireless that VOD owns.
VZ, which owns 55$ of Verizon Wireless, recently agreed to buy the other 45% from VOD for around $130 billion.
From what I can tell so far, the deal will be good for VZ. And, at the very least, VOD gets a boatload of cash and stock. In hindsight, VZ would have been a lot better off striking the same deal in March, before the Fed began hinting that it was thinking of ending the current post-recession period of extra-super-accommodative money policy in the US. The interest rate VZ would have paid on newly issued bonds would have been lower.
More on this topic in future posts.
There may not be a great need to load up on VZ ( which I own) immediately, however–even if you think the deal is a spectacular coup for VZ (too enthusiastic for me). The reason is flowback.
what flowback is
VZ is going to issue over a billion shares of new stock to VOD as part of the purchase price. VOD has already announced it will distribute to its shareholders all of the VZ stock it receives. That’s something like one VZ share for every 40 VOD shares held (the exact ratio isn’t important).
What is important is that VOD is a UK corporation whose stock is traded in London. The bulk of its shares are held either by UK or Continental European institutions. US institutions hold only about 15%.
Put another way, early next year almost everyone who owns VOD will receive shares in a foreign stock, VZ.
What will they do with it?
For index funds, the answer is clear. If it’s not in the index, it has to be sold.
For institutional managers in the EU, the answer depends, in the first instance, on what their contracts with customers say. They’ve presumably been hired for their expertise in EU equities. Management agreements probably stipulate that they’re not allowed to hold non-European securities.
Even if they are permitted to hold VZ, why do it? Why take the risk of holding a stock that’s outside your area of competence–and which will require considerable research effort to get a firm grasp on. Selling is a much safer option.
For individuals, if form runs true, the first they’ll hear of the deal will be when their broker calls to tell them that shares of VZ have plopped into their accounts–and to urge them to get rid of this weird thing.
It happens in all cross-border deals that involve stock. When shares of the issuing company leave the home country, some portion will be sold immediately by investors who are unable or unwilling to hold what is for them a foreign stock.
Where do these sales take place? …ultimately in the home market of the issuer.
the VZ case
For VZ, average daily trading volume is around 10 million – 12 million shares. Occasionally, volume can get as high as 30 million- 40 million shares without moving the stock too much.
Let’s make up a number and say that flowback will be 300 million shares. That’s easily an entire month’s trading volume. So this could be a serious issue for VZ’s price.
There are three that I see:
–Verizon Wireless is the largest and most important asset for both VZ and for VOD. Non-index investors in the EU must have wanted exposure to Verizon Wireless to be holding VOD shares. Arguably, they will want to continue to have that exposure and will therefore be less inclined than normal to want to sell. So maybe some will be able to wangle exceptions from their clients.
–trading volume in VZ over the past seven trading days (not including today) has averaged about 25 million, or–let’s say–12 million shares above normal. If this is all merger-related short-selling, which it probably is, then this trading has already created demand for 80+ million shares of VZ when the shorts are covered.
–the stock has a current dividend yield of 4.6%. At some point, this and other VZ fundamentals should provide price support.
Worries about flowback are one reason large cross-world acquisitions involving stock aren’t that common. This one was clearly too big for VZ to do any other way.
My guess is that anticipatory selling in advance of the acquisition will make it hard for VZ to go up for a while. I also think, however, that downward pressure from potential flowback will abate long before the deal actually occurs.
At some point, an excellent buying opportunity for VZ will emerge from acquisition-related stock activity. The trick is deciding exactly when. The most prudent strategy, I think, is to establish a small position and await further developments.