preliminary 1Q13 results
In conjunction with arranging a five-year $1.75 billion loan through Goldman, JCP has filed an 8-k in which it gives preliminary information about the April 2013 quarter.
–Sales were $2.635 billion, down 16.4% year-on-year (comp store sales = -16.6%). Looking at a two-year comparison, sales are down by 33.2% from (the pre-Ron Johnson) 1Q11.
–Cash on hand at the end of 4Q12 was $930 million. During 1Q13, JCP borrowed an additional $850 million, by drawing half its beefed-up bank credit line. As of May 4th, the company had cash of $821 million. In other words, JCP has blown through the entire $850 million, plus another $109 million in three months.
1. When things go wrong, they often have a runaway train character. Ron Johnson joined JCP in late 2011. Almost immediately, sales went into a tailspin. By mid-2012 it was clear that something was desperately wrong and needed to be fixed.
But no one acts right away. There’s always the temptation to wait just a little while longer in hopes the tide will change.
In addition, a company’s plans may be set in stone months in advance. There are advertising campaigns, construction plans, and billions of dollars of (the wrong) merchandise in the stores–with more of the same on order.
In this case, nine months after starting to back away from the Johnson strategy, JCP is still losing cash at the rate of over $250 million a month.
2. Cash tells the story, in a trouble company. That’s cash flow, cash on hand and cash the company can borrow.
In the JCP case:
–cash flow is -$250 a month,
–cash on hand is $821 million, and
–borrowing power is $2.6 billion (the $1.75 billion loan arranged by Goldman plus the remaining $850 million in JCP’s bank credit line).
Assuming its banks don’t get cold feet and withdraw the credit line, JCP has total cash available of $3.4 billion. That’s enough to sustain a cash drain at the 1Q13 rate for another 13 months.
3. Riding coattails is a risky business. The Financial Times website posted an article last evening titled “Tips from Wall Street gurus fail to reward faithful.” In it, the FT looks at the performance of the hedge fund “best ideas” presented at last year’s Ira Sohn conference in New York. In the aggregate, the tips underperformed the S&P 500. Some, like JCP, were unbelievable clunkers.
–even the best equity managers are wrong 40% of the time, and
–some managers become celebrities mostly through their own aggressive marketing efforts rather than by having stellar performance. Or they parlay a one- or two-year hot streak into an entire career. Caveat emptor.